The Virginia Perennial Cool-Season
Grass Forage Variety Report:
A 3-Year Summary (2002-2004)

Authors: S.R. Smith, Forage Extension Specialist, Virginia Tech; C.D. Teutsch, Forage Research Agronomist, Southern Piedmont AREC; W.E. Thomason, Grains Extension Specialist, Virginia Tech; D.E. Starner, Superintendent, Northern Piedmont AREC; E.G. Rucker, Research Associate, Virginia Tech; G.B. Benson, Research Associate, Virginia Tech; and D.R. Dixon, Senior Agriculture Manager, Northern Piedmont AREC

Publication Number 418-200, Posted October 2005

Perennial cool-season forage grasses are the foundation of ruminant livestock production systems in Virginia. Sound management of these grasses begins with proper species and variety selection. This report is a summary of forage variety trials performed with perennial cool-season grasses at Virginia Tech Agricultural Research and Extension Centers (ARECs) from 2002 through 2004. It includes trials seeded at the Southern Piedmont AREC (SPAREC) at Blackstone and at the Tidewater AREC, Suffolk, September 2001 and harvested for three years (2002 through 2004) (Tables 1 - 8 and 15 - 18). Data from two trials seeded at the Northern Piedmont AREC (NPAREC), Orange, in April 2002 and September 2002 and harvested for two years (2003 and 2004; Tables 9 - 14 and 19 - 24) also are included. The trials were conducted at multiple locations within the state in order to provide a range of environments.

The tables that follow include summary data of individual harvests within years (presented in pounds of dry matter per acre) and total season yields across years (presented in tons of dry matter per acre). The trials include tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea Schreb.) and orchardgrass (Dactylis glomerata L.). The varieties were submitted by or specifically requested of cooperating seed companies with appropriate standard varieties included as checks.

All entries in a trial at a location were harvested on the same dates, but harvest dates varied among locations and years. The goal was to harvest in May, June, August, and a final harvest between October and December for a total of four harvests per year. Entries were planted in four replications of a randomized complete block design at each location. Individual plot size averaged 5 feet by 15 feet. All data were reported on a 100 percent dry matter basis; hay yields would be 10 percent to 15 percent higher. The variety trials were managed at high fertility levels. Phosphorus and potassium were maintained in the high range, and 225 to 300 pounds of nitrogen were applied per acre annually in split applications. At each harvest, plots were cut to a three-inch residual height with either a sickle or flail harvester.

Statistical analyses were performed for individual harvests within years and for total season yields across years. These analyses determine whether numerical differences are just random effects or indeed are "true" differences in performance among varieties. The term "LSD (0.05)" appears at the bottom of each table with an accompanying value under each column of data. An LSD (0.05) is the amount by which two varieties' yields in the same column must differ in order to be considered statistically, or meaningfully, different.

Precipitation has a profound effect on forage yield and persistence. Monthly average precipitation data are presented relative to long-term averages for each location at which the trials were conducted (Figs. 1, 2, and 3). At Orange and Blackstone, there was below average precipitation in 2002, above average precipitation in 2003, and near average precipitation in 2004 until fall when hurricane rains dramatically increased seasonal totals. Interestingly, 2002 was the driest year on record at Blackstone and 2003 was the wettest year on record. Tidewater irrigated its tall fescue plots in 2002, but not in 2003 and 2004.

When using this publication to select perennial grass forage varieties, it is important to 1) prioritize the relative importance of yield, persistence, and quality for the intended use of the forage and 2) understand the context within which these trials were conducted. These trials did not determine forage quality or palatability. These data reflect the yield and persistence of varieties under optimum management as monocultures. Neither variety compatibility with legumes nor soil adaptation were determined. Varieties that persisted well over several years in these trials may not necessarily persist well under grazing, poor fertility, or a broader range of soil types. Consult your local Extension agent for more information about forage varieties and management.

Acknowledgements

The researchers express their appreciation to the participating seed companies for their financial support of these trials. We are also indebted to Dean Sharron Quisenberry, Former Dean Andy Swiger, and Crop and Soil Environmental Sciences Department Head Steve Hodges for their support. Many thanks also to A. Ozzie Abaye and Glenn Johnson for their critical reviews of this publication. We want to thank Carol Wilkinson, SPAREC director, Jim Jones, former SPAREC director, and Fred Shokes, TAREC director, for their support of this research. Thanks, too, to the AREC employees, especially Steve Gulick and Alvin Hood at the NPAREC and Ned Jones at the SPAREC, and the undergraduate student workers who provided valuable assistance in conducting the trials.

Listing of Tables

2002-2004 Tall Fescue Forage Variety Trials

Southern Piedmont AREC, Blackstone, Va.

Tidewater AREC, Suffolk, Va.

Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va.

2003-2004 Orchardgrass Forage Variety Trials

Southern Piedmont AREC, Blackstone, Va.

Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va.


2002-2004 Tall Fescue Forage Variety Trials

Table 1. 2002 Fescue Variety Yields - Southern Piedmont AREC, Blackstone, Va., September 2001 Seeding.

Variety 6-May-02 3-Jul-02 19-Dec-02 Total 2002
  Yield (lb dry matter/A)
JesupMax-Q 4,733 968 4,208 9,909
(E+)TN 4,478 1,132 4,142 9,753
CAS-EA200 4,597 1,109 3,996 9,701
Bronson 4,721 965 3,955 9,640
(E-)KY 3,868 1,297 4,387 9,551
(E+)KY 3,738 1,355 4,379 9,471
Resolute-AR542 4,614 691 3,849 9,154
Q4508 3,595 1,574 3,824 8,994
Quincy 4,508 738 3,726 8,972
Carmine 3,838 1,449 3,612 8,899
(E-)TN 3,945 1,078 3,869 8,892
Rogue 4,869 500 3,392 8,761
KYFA9304 3,317 1,328 4,069 8,714
KYFA9301 3,133 1,425 4,126 8,685
K5666V 3,364 789 2,984 7,138
Kokanee 2,168 1,429 2,503 6,101
Average 3,968 1,114 3,814 8,896
LSD (0.05) 739 344 648 1,262
04-Oct-01 - Seeded
28-Jan-02 - 1.5 pt/A Banvel + 2,4-D with 0.5% surfactant
22-Feb-02 - 1000 lb/A 10-10-10
07-May-02 - 1000 lb/A 10-20-20
20-Aug-02 - 100 lb N/A

Table 2. 2003 Fescue Variety Yields - Southern Piedmont AREC, Blackstone, Va., September 2001 Seeding.

Variety 2-May-03 8-Jul-03 28-Aug-03 16-Dec-03 Total 2003
  Yield (lb dry matter/A)
Quincy7,5023,9861,3924,17817,059
(E+)KY6,6714,5561,2224,28916,738
CAS-EA2006,2924,3081,1794,64216,421
KYFA93046,9954,3411,1373,90316,376
JesupMax-Q6,4744,1071,3214,30716,209
(E-)KY6,1324,5831,4073,95416,075
Rogue6,7124,3151,0873,67115,784
Bronson6,6983,3771,3004,15215,527
(E+)TN6,0224,2481,1303,93715,336
KYFA93015,6574,5161,1373,57614,885
(E-)TN5,4924,1071,1444,13514,877
Q45085,2963,4911,3854,12614,298
K5666V5,2364,1471,4143,06013,857
Carmine5,4283,1621,0233,67113,284
Kokanee5,3603,7521,4001,84812,359
Resolute-AR5421,6543,3302,0892,2879,359
Average5,8514,0201,2983,73314,903
LSD (0.05)1,8104874085431,953
04-Oct-01 - Seeded
12-Mar-03 - Applied 666 lb/A 15-5-20
9-May-03 - Applied 666 lb/A 15-5-20
29-Aug-03 - Applied 666 lb/A 15-5-20

Table 3. 2004 Fescue Variety Yields - Southern Piedmont AREC, Blackstone, Va., September 2001 Seeding.
Variety 30-Apr-04 24-Jun-04 7-Sep-04 8-Dec-04 Total 2004
  Yield (lb dry matter/A)
(E+)KY2,1462,1152,0393,5609,859
Quincy2,3601,7721,9423,2729,346
CAS-EA2002,4292,1571,8532,8969,335
Q45082,7131,8261,7842,7969,117
Bronson2,3471,9151,8802,9109,051
JesupMax-Q2,1961,9451,5703,2989,009
(E+)TN2,8891,0391,9633,0448,934
(E-)KY2,0521,7711,8803,1788,880
Carmine2,3101,8651,8322,8298,836
(E-)TN1,9321,9561,6393,1118,638
KYFA93042,0331,5022,0183,0848,637
KYFA93011,8131,4091,8602,9778,057
K5666V1,5671,6531,6122,4147,245
Rogue1,4351,2421,6812,6827,039
Kokanee9381,8482,6241,4216,831
Resolute-AR5427624823,7331,6696,645
Average1,9951,6561,9942,8218,466
LSD (0.05)4324413995231,119
04-Oct-01 - Seeded
23-Feb-04 - Applied 1 ton/A lime
03-Mar-04 - Applied 100 lb/A liquid nitrogen
19-May-04 - Applied 666 lb/A 15-5-20
22-Sept-04 - Applied 100 lb/A 15-5-20

Table 4. Fescue Variety Yields - Southern Piedmont AREC, Blackstone, Va., September 2001 Seeding.

Variety 2002 2003 2004 2002-2004 Avg.
  Yield (ton dry matter/A)
(E+)KY 4.74 8.37 4.93 6.01
CAS-EA200 4.85 8.21 4.67 5.91
Quincy 4.49 8.53 4.67 5.90
JesupMax-Q 4.95 8.10 4.50 5.85
(E-)KY 4.78 8.04 4.44 5.75
Bronson 4.82 7.76 4.53 5.70
(E+)TN 4.88 7.67 4.47 5.67
KYFA9304 4.36 8.19 4.32 5.62
(E-)TN 4.45 7.44 4.32 5.40
Q4508 4.50 7.15 4.56 5.40
KYFA9301 4.34 7.44 4.03 5.27
Rogue 4.38 7.89 3.52 5.26
Carmine 4.45 6.64 4.42 5.17
K5666V 3.57 6.93 3.62 4.71
Kokanee 3.05 6.18 3.42 4.22
Resolute-AR542 4.58 4.68 3.32 4.19
Average 4.45 7.45 4.23 5.38
LSD (0.05) 0.63 0.98 0.56 0.42
17-Aug-01 - Applied Roundup
29-Aug-01 - Applied Gramoxone
13-Sept-01 - Irrigated 1"
17-Sept-01 - Plowed down 1 ton/A lime
21-Sept-01 - Disked down 600 lb/A 7-20-20; ripped at 12"
04-Oct-01 - Seeded
09-Oct-01 - Irrigated 0.5"
Soil Type: Appling-Cecil
Soil Test: September 2001
pH: 5.9
P: MK:
MCa:
Low +
Mg: M+

2002-2004 Tall Fescue Forage Variety Trials

Table 5. 2002 Fescue Variety Yields - Tidewater AREC, Suffolk, Va., September 2001 Seeding.
Variety 30-Apr-02 12-Jul-02 11-Sep-02 14-Jan-03 Total 2002
  Yield (lb dry matter/A)
KY31 (E+) TN 5,281 6,565 2,190 4,961 18,997
Jesup MaxQ 5,639 5,851 1,648 4,300 17,437
KY31 (E+) KY 4,153 6,001 2,287 4,527 16,967
KYFA 9301 3,836 6,396 2,427 4,011 16,670
KY31 (E-) KY 4,458 5,403 2,205 4,069 16,136
KY31 (E-) TN 4,088 5,336 2,102 4,210 15,735
Bronson 4,746 4,151 1,902 4,492 15,291
Quincy 4,540 3,982 2,028 4,621 15,171
KYFA 9304 3,548 4,952 2,242 3,929 14,671
CAS-EA200 3,783 3,982 2,065 4,081 13,910
K5666V 3,812 4,117 1,902 3,976 13,807
Resolute-AR542 5,081 1,083 1,362 6,133 13,659
Kokanee 1,674 4,140 2,257 3,026 11,097
Potomac OG 4,182 2,594 1,265 1,689 9,731
Average 4,201 4,611 1,992 4,144 14,948
LSD (0.05) 1,067 1,956 385 616 2,817
10-Oct-01 - Seeded
7-Mar-02 - Applied 1000 lb/A 10-10-10
30-Apr-02 - Applied 80 lb/A N using ammonium nitrate
11-Sept-02 - Applied 100 lb N/A

Table 6. 2003 Fescue Variety Yields - Tidewater AREC, Suffolk, Va., September 2001 Seeding.
Variety 29-Apr-03 16-Jul-03 14-Jan-04 Total 2003
  Yield (lb dry matter/A)
Quincy 5,841 1,654 4,147 11,643
KY31 (E+) TN 5,289 1,716 4,519 11,524
Bronson 5,412 1,315 4,124 10,851
Jesup MaxQ 5,848 1,315 3,640 10,804
CAS-EA200 6,058 1,192 3,485 10,735
KY31 (E-) TN 5,244 1,541 3,915 10,701
KYFA 9301 5,239 1,624 3,601 10,464
KY31 (E+) KY 5,072 1,531 3,857 10,460
KY31 (E-) KY 5,283 1,459 3,625 10,367
KYFA 9304 5,133 1,336 3,404 9,873
K5666V 4,057 1,552 3,903 9,512
Resolute-AR542 4,826 884 3,636 9,346
Kokanee 3,885 2,137 2,591 8,613
Potomac OG 5,317 904 1,673 7,894
Average 5,179 1,440 3,580 10,199
LSD (0.05) 520 325 533 858
10-Oct-01 - Seeded
4-Mar-03 - Applied 600 lb/A 15-5-20
11-Sept-03 - 150 lb/A 15-5-20

Table 7. 2004 Fescue Variety Yields - Tidewater AREC, Suffolk, Va., September 2001 Seeding.
Variety 6-May-04 22-Jun-04 23-Sep-04 9-Feb-05 Total 2004
  Yield (lb dry matter/A)
KY31(E+)TN 3,688 3,742 2,528 2,761 12,719
Quincy 4,094 2,960 2,471 2,444 11,967
KY31(E+)KY 3,198 3,451 2,557 2,688 11,893
KYFA9301 3,872 3,226 2,002 2,529 11,628
KY31(E-)KY 3,728 3,281 2,068 2,150 11,227
KY31(E-)TN 3,623 3,262 1,800 2,309 10,717
CAS-EA200 3,787 2,880 1,868 2,102 10,635
JesupMaxQ 3,689 3,347 1,466 1,943 10,443
Bronson 3,976 2,737 1,437 2,236 9,911
KYFA9304 3,309 2,662 1,686 1,991 9,649
K5666V 3,093 2,760 1,619 1,503 8,974
PotomacOG 4,199 2,323 967 440 7,929
Kokanee 1,962 2,778 1,944 660 7,343
Resolute-AR542 2,472 1,496 - 1,625 -
Average 3,478 2,922 1,897 1,956 10,400
LSD (0.05) 298 769 591 460 757
10-Oct-01 - Seeded
8-Mar-04 - 100 lb/A N using UAN
6-May-04 - Applied 150 lb/A 15-5-20

Table 8. Fescue Variety Yields - Tidewater AREC, Suffolk, Va., September 2001 Seeding.
Variety 2002 2003 2004 2002-2004 Avg.
  Yield (ton dry matter/A)
Resolute-AR542 6.83 4.67 - 5.75
Quincy 7.59 5.82 5.98 6.46
Potomac OG 4.87 3.95 3.96 4.26
KYFA 9304 7.34 4.94 4.82 5.70
KYFA 9301 8.33 5.23 5.81 6.46
KY31 (E+) TN 9.50 5.76 6.36 7.21
KY31 (E+) KY 8.48 5.23 5.95 6.55
KY31 (E-) TN 7.87 5.35 5.36 6.27
KY31 (E-) KY 8.07 5.18 5.61 6.29
Kokanee 5.55 4.31 3.67 4.51
K5666V 6.90 4.76 4.49 5.38
Jesup MaxQ 8.72 5.40 5.22 6.45
CAS-EA200 6.96 5.37 5.32 5.88
Bronson 7.65 5.43 4.96 6.22
Average 7.47 5.10 5.20 5.96
LSD (0.05) 1.41 0.43 0.38 0.52

2003-2004 Tall Fescue Forage Variety Trials

Table 9. 2003 Fescue Variety Yields - Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va., April 2002 Seeding.
Variety 22-May-03 12-May-03 15-Jul-03 8-Sep-03 3-Nov-03 Total 2003
  % Stand Yield (lb dry matter/A)
KY31E1 KY 95 3,464 4,498 1,221 1,239 10,421
KY31 E(-)TN 90 3,117 4,443 1,393 1,342 10,295
HM-R 89 3,297 4,468 1,337 1,178 10,280
KY31 E(+)TN 90 3,600 4,303 1,209 1,102 10,214
KYFA 93O4 88 2,711 4,217 1,559 1,526 10,012
SELECT 88 3,182 4,028 1,344 1,365 9,920
Q4508 F542 93 3,085 3,821 1,184 1,633 9,722
BAR FA 1004 79 3,044 3,818 1,289 1,570 9,720
QUINCEY 85 3,141 4,234 1,188 926 9,490
KY31EF KY 85 2,892 4,060 1,285 1,149 9,386
CAS-EA200 78 2,958 3,801 1,281 1,325 9,366
KYFA 93O1 92 2,771 4,098 1,113 981 8,963
JESUP MAX Q 88 3,001 3,577 1,220 1,145 8,942
BRONSON 73 2,769 3,261 1,240 1,262 8,532
AGR FA lll 61 2,010 3,457 1,104 1,188 7,759
ROGUE 65 2,223 3,095 1,236 1,022 7,574
RESOLUTE 49 1,960 2,256 1,131 1,023 6,368
KS666V 40 1,960 2,509 977 840 6,286
KOKANEE 41 1,355 2,620 991 666 5,632
AGR LP 113 71 2,423 1,733 603 628 5,387
R4663F542 35 1,228 1,680 863 769 4,540
Average 75 2,676 3,523 1,179 1,137 8,515
LSD (0.05) 19 687 973 336 397 1,426
04-Apr-02 - Seeded
10-Mar-03 - Applied 100-100-100/A
15-May-03 - Applied 50 lb/A N
20-May-03 - Applied 185 lb/A K2O
08-Sept-03 - Applied 75 lb/A N

Table 10. 2004 Fescue Variety Yields - Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va., April 2002 Seeding.
Variety 21-Apr-04 5-May-04 9-Jun-04 26-Aug-04 16-Nov-04 Total 2004
 % Stand Yield (lb dry matter/A)
KY31 E(-)TN 94 5,387 2,628 2,523 2,791 13,328
BAR FA 1004 93 53,38 2,513 2,417 2,866 13,133
JESUP MAX Q 95 5,123 2,474 2,278 2,704 12,578
KY31E1 KY 95 4,098 3,077 2,437 2,657 12,269
Q4508 F542 99 5,059 2,485 1,960 2,722 12,226
KY31 E(+)TN 97 4,333 2,651 2,326 2,893 12,202
HM-R 94 4,467 2,798 2,246 2,678 12,189
KYFA 93O4 95 4,343 2,825 2,227 2,710 12,105
CAS-EA200 91 4,182 2,572 2,145 2,606 11,505
QUINCEY 97 4,456 2,329 2,097 2,482 11,364
SELECT 95 4,194 2,542 2,064 2,521 11,320
KYFA 93O1 97 4,021 2,720 1,942 2,586 11,267
KY31EF KY 90 3,917 2,533 2,213 2,585 11,247
BRONSON 88 3,947 2,453 1,928 2,603 10,931
AGR FA lll 71 4,134 2,260 1,904 2,520 10,818
ROGUE 80 3,838 2,275 1,671 1,732 9,516
KOKANEE 45 2,343 2,827 1,696 1,779 8,644
KS666V 55 3,244 2,220 1,174 1,870 8,508
R4663F542 41 2,697 2,111 1,082 2,417 8,307
RESOLUTE 45 2,225 1,993 673 2,100 6,991
AGR LP 113 51 2,093 1,741 1,347 1,661 6,842
Average 81 3,973 2477 1,921 2,451 10,823
LSD (0.05) 17 713 280 534 319 1,431
04-Apr-02 - Seeded
09-Apr-04 - Sprayed 1 pt/A Banvel and 2 pt/A 2,4-D
07-May-04 - Applied 185 lb/A K2O
07-May-04 - Applied 50 lb/A N from ammonium nitrate
26-Aug-04 - Applied 75 lb/A N from ammonium nitrate

Table 11. Fescue Variety Yields - Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va., April 2002 Seeding.
Variety 2003 20042003-2004 A
 Yield (ton dry matter/A)
KY31 E(-)TN 5.15 6.665.91
BAR FA 1004 4.86 6.575.71
KY31E1 KY 5.21 6.135.67
HM-R 5.14 6.10 5.62
KY31 E(+)TN 5.11 6.10 5.60
KYFA 93O4 5.01 6.05 5.53
Q4508 F542 4.86 6.11 5.49
JESUP MAX Q 4.47 6.29 5.38
SELECT 4.96 5.66 5.31
CAS-EA200 4.68 5.75 5.22
QUINCEY 4.75 5.68 5.21
KY31EF KY 4.69 5.63 5.16
KYFA 93O1 4.48 5.64 5.06
BRONSON 4.27 5.47 4.87
AGR FA lll 3.88 5.41 4.64
ROGUE 3.79 4.76 4.28
KS666V 3.14 4.26 3.70
KOKANEE 2.82 4.33 3.57
RESOLUTE 3.19 3.50 3.34
R4663F542 2.27 4.15 3.21
AGR LP 113 2.69 3.42 3.06
Average 4.26 5.41 4.83
LSD (0.05) 0.71 0.72 0.50
07-Mar-02 - Disked
04-Apr-02 - Seeded
05-Apr-02 - Cultipacked
16-Apr-02 - Irrigated 0.6"
18-Apr-02 - Irrigated 0.6"
03-May-02 - Irrigated 0.3"

2003-2004 Tall Fescue Forage Variety Trials

Table 12. 2003 Fescue Variety Yields Ð Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va., September 2002 Seeding.
Variety 22-May-03 13-May-03 16-Jul-03 5-Sep-03 31-Oct-03 T
 % Stand Yield (lb dry matter/A)
KYFA93-04 99 3,514 4,514 1,304 1,401 10,733
AGR-FA2845 93 2,997 4,720 1,376 1,445 10,538
KY 31+ 98 3,122 4,797 1,242 1,348 10,509
AGR-FA106 97 2,851 4,491 1,364 1,686 10,392
QUINCEY 96 2,812 5,014 1,226 1,302 10,354
SELECT 99 2,898 4,350 1,458 1,556 10,262
KYFA93-01 96 2,669 4,496 1,668 1,330 10,164
QUANTUM 542 98 2,628 3,997 1,443 1,939 10,007
KY 31- 96 2,865 4,605 1,062 1,337 9,869
ARK PLUS 95 2,468 4,444 1,516 1,307 9,735
CAS-EA200 91 2,386 4,311 1,385 1,558 9,641
AGR-FA114 97 2,852 4,393 1,087 1,277 9,610
BRONSON 93 2,275 3,960 1,608 1,719 9,563
QUANTUM 542 91 2,168 3,750 1,538 2,079 9,535
JESUP MAX Q 91 2,102 4,183 1,509 1,708 9,502
BAROLEX 95 2,222 4,340 1,275 1,309 9,146
BARCEL 97 2,097 4,093 1,295 1,549 9,034
AGR-FA111 93 1,907 4,537 1,081 1,302 8,828
BARIANE 91 2,191 3,898 906 1,296 8,291
KS666V 89 1,897 3,479 951 1,157 7,484
RESOLUTE 67 466 2,740 405 754 4,364
Average 93 2,447 4,244 1,271 1,444 9,406
LSD (0.05) 9 469 566 332 353 891
10-Sept-02 - Seeded
10-Mar-03 - Applied 100-100-100/A
15-Apr-03 - Sprayed 1/2 pt/A Banvel and 1 pt/A 2,4-D
15-May-03 - Applied 50 lb/A nitrogen
08-Sept-03 - Applied 75 lb/A nitrogen

Table 13. 2004 Fescue Variety Yields - Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va., September 2002 Seeding.
Variety 21-Apr-04 4-May-04 8-Jun-04 17-Aug-04 16-Nov-04 Total 2004
 % Stand Yield (lb dry matter/A)
KYFA93-04 93 3,816 2,863 2,319 3,065 12,063
QUANTUM 95 4,818 2,385 2,066 2,787 12,055
QUANTUM 542 97 4,274 2,589 1,891 3,112 11,866
JESUP MAX Q 93 4,691 2,533 1,868 2,718 11,811
QUINCEY 93 3,979 2,729 2,022 3,004 11,734
KY 31+ 95 3,362 3,242 2,178 2,787 11,569
AGR-FA2845 95 4,356 2,307 1,914 2,873 11,449
ARK PLUS 94 3,520 2,639 2,105 2,986 11,250
AGR-FA106 94 4,364 2,326 1,684 2,658 11,032
KY 31- 95 3,485 2,838 1,725 2,749 10,797
BARCEL 89 3,412 2,777 2,099 2,443 10,731
BRONSON 90 3,883 2,490 1,716 2,577 10,666
KYFA93-01 92 3,276 2,696 1,960 2,657 10,588
AGR-FA114 96 3,431 2,400 1,708 2,978 10,516
BAROLEX 91 3,500 2,537 1,512 2,849 10,398
CAS-EA200 94 3,917 2,463 1,242 2,517 10,138
AGR-FA111 90 3,190 2,233 1,647 2,882 9,952
SELECT 95 3,832 2,829 20 2,679 9,361
BARIANE 89 2,509 2,838 1,474 2,478 9,299
KS666V 90 2,672 2,217 966 1,876 7,731
RESOLUTE 86 2,504 1,553 725 1,639 6,421
Average 93 3,657 2,547 1,659 2,681 10,544
LSD (0.05)4 378 289 611 322 1,318
10-Sept-02 - Seeded
26-Feb-04 - Applied 1000 lb/A 10-10-10-6S
07-May-04 - Applied 185 lb/A K2O
07-May-04 - Applied 50 lb/A N from ammonium nitrate
18-Aug-04 - Applied 75 lb/A N from ammonium nitrate

Table 14. Fescue Variety Yields - Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va., September 2002 Seeding.
Variety 2003 20042003-2004 Avg.
 Yield (ton dry matter/A)
KYFA93-04 5.37 6.035.70
QUINCEY 5.18 5.875.52
KY 31+ 5.25 5.785.52
AGR-FA2845 5.27 5.725.50
QUANTUM 542 5.00 5.935.47
QUANTUM 4.77 6.035.40
JESUP MAX Q 4.83 5.91 5.37
AGR-FA106 5.20 5.52 5.36
ARK PLUS 4.87 5.63 5.25
KYFA93-01 5.08 5.29 5.19
KY 31- 4.93 5.40 5.17
BRONSON 4.78 5.33 5.06
AGR-FA114 4.81 5.26 5.03
CAS-EA200 4.81 5.07 4.94
BARCEL 4.51 5.37 4.94
SELECT 5.13 4.68 4.91
BAROLEX 4.57 5.20 4.89
AGR-FA111 4.41 4.98 4.69
BARIANE 4.07 4.65 4.36
KS666V 3.74 3.87 3.80
RESOLUTE 2.18 3.21 2.70
Average 4.70 5.27 4.99
LSD (0.05) 0.45 0.66 0.39
04-Sept-02 - Disked and cultimulched
05-Sept-02 - Applied 500 lb/A 5-10-10-3S
10-Sept-02 - Seeded
10-Sept-02 - Cultipacked
12-Sept-02 - Irrigated 0.6"
04-Oct-02 - Irrigated 0.6"

2002-2004 Orchardgrass Forage Variety Trials

Table 15. 2002 Orchardgrass Variety Yields - Southern Piedmont AREC, Blackstone, Va., October 2001 Seeding
Variety 18-Apr-02 4-Jun-0219-Dec-02 Total 2002
 Yield (lb dry matter/A)
CAS-EG39/42 2,818 3,2041,931 7,953
Tekapo 2,776 2,960 2,006 7,742
Eastwood 2,355 3,015 2,024 7,394
Benchmark 2,892 2,749 1,679 7,320
GAOG1 2,976 2,771 1,539 7,287
CISOG28 2,060 2,849 1,922 6,830
Amba 2,413 2,794 1,091 6,298
AberTop 1,270 3,514 1,399 6,183
Average 2,445 2,982 1,699 7,126
LSD (0.05) 630 503 651 1,019
04-Oct-01 - seeded
22-Feb-02 - 1000 lb/A 10-10-10
01-Apr-02 - 1 ton/A lime
07-May-02 - 1000 lb/A 10-20-20
20-Aug-02 - 100 lb/A N

Table 16. 2003 Orchardgrass Variety Yields - Southern Piedmont AREC, Blackstone, Va., October 2001 Seeding.
Variety 24-Apr-03 8-Jul-0328-Aug-0316-Dec-03Total 2003
 Yield (lb dry matter/A)
CAS-EG39/42 4,002 4,752 1,575 1,985 12,313
Benchmark 3,922 4,516 1,566 1,582 11,587
CISOG28 3,181 4,679 1,601 1,993 11,455
Tekapo 3,344 4,570 1,566 1,958 11,439
GAOG1 3,946 4,289 1,540 1,373 11,147
AberTop 2,159 5,361 1,925 1,294 10,739
Amba 2,850 4,861 1,610 1,381 10,702
Eastwood 1,660 5,479 1,531 1,687 10,358
Average 3,133 4,813 1,614 1,657 11,218
LSD (0.05)350 473 324 421 823
04-Oct-01 - seeded
12-Mar-03 - 666 lb/A 15-5-20
25-Apr-03 - 666 lb/A 15-5-20
29-Aug-03 - 666 lb/A 15-5-20

Table 17. 2004 Orchardgrass Variety Yields - Southern Piedmont AREC, Blackstone, Va., October 2001 Seeding.
Variety 30-Apr-04 2-Jul-0421-Sep-049-Dec-04Total 2004
 Yield (lb dry matter/A)
CAS-EG39/42 3,049 3,284 1,887 2,088 10,308
Benchmark 2,634 3,075 2,105 2,002 9,815
Tekapo 1,842 3,181 2,077 2,148 9,248
CISOG28 1,851 3,057 1,715 2,094 8,716
GAOG1 2,315 2,626 1,733 1,911 8,583
Eastwood 144 3,495 1,651 1,814 7,104
Amba 186 3,241 1,596 1,782 6,806
AberTop 62 3,464 1,488 1,679 6,694
Average 1,510 3,178 1,781 1,940 8,409
LSD (0.05) 898 428 511 203 1,200
04-Oct-01 - seeded
23-Feb-04 - 1 ton/A lime
19-May-04 - 666 lb/A 15-5-20
22-Sept-04 - 666 lb/A 15-5-20

Table 18. Orchardgrass Variety Yields - Southern Piedmont AREC, Blackstone, Va., October 2001 Seeding.
Variety 2002 2003 2004 2002-2004 Avg.
  Yield (ton dry matter/A)
CAS-EG39/42 3.98 6.16 5.15 5.10
Benchmark 3.66 5.79 4.91 4.79
Tekapo 3.87 5.72 4.62 4.74
CISOG28 3.42 5.73 4.36 4.50
GAOG1 3.64 5.57 4.29 4.50
Eastwood 3.70 5.18 3.55 4.14
Amba 3.15 5.35 3.40 3.97
AberTop 3.09 5.37 3.35 3.94
Average 3.56 5.61 4.20 4.46
LSD (0.05) 0.51 0.41 0.60 0.28
17-Aug-01 - Roundup
29-Aug-01 - Gramoxone
13-Sept-01 - 1" irrigation
17-Sept-01 - plow
21-Sept-01 - 600 lb/A 7-20-20 disked down; ripped at 12"
04-Oct-01 - seeded
09-Oct-01 - 0.5" irrigation
04-Dec-01 - 0.1 oz/A Ally
Soil Type: Appling-Cecil
Soil Test: September 2001
pH: 5.8
P: L
K: L
Ca: L
Mg: M

2003-2004 Orchardgrass Forage Variety Trials

Table 19. 2003 Orchardgrass Variety Yields - Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va., April 2002 Seeding.
Variety 22-May-03 7-May-03 15-Jul-03 8-Sep-03 31-Oct-03 Total 2003
 % Stand Yield (lb dry matter/A)
GA OG1 98 4,764 3,533 568 288 9,152
OG 9705-G 96 4,107 3,859 631 502 9,098
CAS-EG39/42 95 4,002 4,079 625 344 9,050
BENCHMARK PLUS 98 4,085 3,753 636 419 8,893
BENCHMARK 96 3,924 3,770 543 450 8,687
CIS OG28 96 3,538 3,963 657 417 8,575
TEKAPO 94 3,738 3,847 585 388 8,558
WP 300 95 3,517 3,687 485 417 8,106
EASTWOOD 79 1,402 3,832 635 479 6,348
ABER TOP 45 496 2,941 668 405 4,509
Average 89 3,357 3,726 603 411 8,097
LSD (0.05)13 607 513 152 186 896
04-Apr-02 - Seeded
10-Mar-03 - Applied 1000 lb/A 10-10-10 fertilizer
15-May-03 - Applied 50 lb/A N
20-May-03 - Applied 185 lb/A K20
08-Sept-03 - Applied 75 lb/A N

Table 20. 2004 Orchardgrass Variety Yields - Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va., April 2002 Seeding.
Variety 21-Apr-04 5-May-04 8-Jun-04 25-Aug-04 16-Nov-04 Total 2004
 % Stand Yield (lb dry matter/A)
CAS-EG39/42 96 4,404 1,930 1,473 1,998 9,806
GA OG1 98 4,687 1,609 1,450 2,024 9,769
OG 9705-G 98 4,571 1,730 1,379 2,006 9,686
BENCHMARK PLUS 98 4,360 1,870 1,385 2,053 9,667
CIS OG28 96 3,880 2,118 1,551 2,017 9,565
BENCHMARK 98 4,362 1,869 1,366 1,869 9,464
WP 300 97 3,641 1,828 1,360 1,946 8,775
TEKAPO 95 3,390 1,875 1,412 1,936 8,613
EASTWOOD 86 2,635 2,250 1,620 2,019 8,525
ABER TOP 75 3,107 1,970 1,576 1,618 8,271
Average 94 3,904 1,905 1,457 1,949 9,214
LSD (0.05) 11 456 184 232 220 610
04-Apr-02 - Seeded
26-Feb-04 - apply 1000 lb/A 10-10-10-6S
09-Apr-04 - Spray with 2 pt/A 2,4-D LV and 1 pt/A Banvel
07-May-04 - 185 lb/A K20 + 50 lb/A ammonium nitrate
26-Aug-04 - applied 75 lb/A N

Table 21. Orchardgrass Variety Yields - Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va., April 2002 Seeding.
Variety 2003 20042003-2004 Avg.
 Yield (ton dry matter/A)
GA OG1 4.58 4.894.73
CAS-EG39/42 4.53 4.914.71
OG 9705-G 4.55 4.844.70
BENCHMARK PLUS 4.45 4.844.64
CIS OG28 4.29 4.784.54
BENCHMARK 4.34 4.734.54
TEKAPO 4.28 4.314.30
WP 300 4.05 4.394.22
EASTWOOD 3.18 4.273.72
ABER TOP 2.26 4.14 3.19
Average 4.05 4.61 4.33
LSD (0.05) 0.45 0.31 0.26
07-Mar-02 - Disked
04-Apr-02 - Seeded
05-Apr-02 - Cultipacked
16-Apr-02 - Irrigated 0.6"
18-Apr-02 - Irrigated 0.6"
03-May-02 - Irrigated 0.3"

2003-2004 Orchardgrass Forage Variety Trials

Table 22. 2003 Orchardgrass Variety Yields - Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va., September 2002 Seeding.
Variety 22-May-03 13-May-03 16-Jul-03 5-Sep-03 31-Oct-03 Total 2003
 % Stand Yield (lb dry matter/A)
CAS-EG39/42 93 2,476 3,601 1,296 831 8,204
BENCHMARK PLUS 94 2,514 3,379 1,060 872 7,826
BENCHMARK 89 2,400 3,365 1,383 672 7,821
WP300 90 2,379 3,484 1,173 769 7,804
CIS OG28 91 2,514 3,423 911 694 7,542
TEKAPO 85 2,280 3,394 984 611 7,269
BARIDANA 91 1,995 3,822 842 574 7,234
GA OG1 91 2,323 3,428 924 492 7,166
BARULA 90 2,107 3,689 611 566 6,972
EASTWOOD 51 562 3,563 1,356 1,035 6,515
ABER TOP 68 598 2,951 951 439 4,939
Average 85 2,014 3,464 1,044 687 7,209
LSD (0.05) 12 460 420 498 188 913
10-Sept-02 - Seeded
10-Mar-03 - Applied 100-100-100 per acre
12-Mar-03 - Applied 2.5 tons/A lime
15-Apr-03 - Sprayed 1/2 pt/A Banvel and 1 pt/A 2,4-D
15-May-03 - Applied 50 lb/A N
08-Sept-03 - Applied 75 lb/A N

Table 23. 2004 Orchardgrass Variety Yields - Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va., September 2002 Seeding.
Variety 21-Apr-04 4-May-04 8-Jun-04 17-Aug-04 18-Nov-04 Total 2004
 % Stand Yield (lb dry matter/A)
GA OG1 99 4,676 1,612 902 1,910 9,099
BENCHMARK PLUS 96 4,192 1,757 1,151 1,837 8,938
CAS-EG39/42 94 4,438 1,594 958 1,874 8,863
CIS OG28 95 4,071 1,535 905 1,986 8,496
WP300 98 4,090 1,627 808 1,897 8,422
BENCHMARK 94 4,069 1,618 852 1,678 8,216
TEKAPO 95 3,392 1,675 914 1,607 7,588
BARIDANA 93 2,741 1,720 788 1,573 6,821
BARULA 88 1,972 2,051 946 1,684 6,653
EASTWOOD 86 2,410 1,702 899 1,615 6,626
ABER TOP 86 1,967 2,037 1,049 1,283 6,335
Average 93 3,456 1,721 924 1,722 7,823
LSD (0.05) 5 413 162 355 327 1,017
10-Sept-02 - Seeded
26-Feb-04 - Applied 1000 lb/A 10-10-10-6S
07-May-04 - Applied 185 lb/A K2O
07-May-04 - Applied 50 lb/A N from ammonium nitrate
18-Aug-04 - Applied 75 lb/A N from ammonium nitrate

Table 24. Orchardgrass Variety Yields - Northern Piedmont AREC, Orange, Va., September 2002 Seeding.
Variety 2003 2004 2003-2004 Avg.
 Yield (ton dry matter/A)
CAS-EG39/42 4.10 4.43 4.27
BENCHMARK PLUS 3.91 4.47 4.19
GA OG1 3.58 4.55 4.07
WP300 3.90 4.21 4.06
CIS OG28 3.77 4.25 4.01
BENCHMARK 3.91 4.11 4.01
TEKAPO 3.64 3.79 3.72
BARIDANA 3.62 3.41 3.51
BARULA 3.49 3.33 3.41
EASTWOOD 3.26 3.31 3.29
ABER TOP 2.47 3.17 2.82
Average 3.60 3.91 3.76
LSD (0.05) 0.46 0.51 0.33
04-Sept-02 - Disked and cultimulched
05-Sept-02 - Applied 500 lb/A 5-
10-Sept-02 - Seeded
10-Sept-02 - Cultipacked
12-Sept-02 - Irrigated 0.6"
04-Oct-02 - Irrigated 0.6"

View this document in PDF format

Visit Virginia Cooperative Extension